150x
005619
2024-10-23

Evaluation of FE Mesh Refinement

Is it possible to quickly evaluate whether the mesh used is fine enough?


Answer:

Yes, you can very quickly estimate whether an FE mesh is fine enough by comparing the averaged and unaveraged results.

Tip

For more information, see the online manual at "Result Smoothing".

In the following, you see a surface with a free rectangular load and lifting line supports. The upper window shows the first principal stresses, smoothed continuously within the surface, and the lower window shows them constant in mesh elements. The meshing increases in the models from left to right.

As you can see at first sight, the correlation improves as the mesh refinement increases. Compared at a selected point, you can see the deviations of the results in the following table.

Deviation of Principal Stresses Due to Result Smoothing
Mesh 0.500 m 0.250 m 0.100 m 0.050 m 0.010 m
Uniform 17.657 MPa 16.614 MPa 17.015 MPa 17.031 MPa 17.045 MPa
Continuous 14.009 MPa 16.104 MPa 16.863 MPa 16.992 MPa 17.043 MPa
Deviation 26.04% 3.17% 0.90% 0.23% 0.01%

A similar behavior can be observed for the strains, as shown in the following image.

This rough evaluation cannot replace a detailed convergence analysis. However, it is recommended to use this procedure as a first estimation.

It should also be noted that this does not work for so-called singularity locations, as the stresses there increase to infinity for an infinite mesh refinement.


Author

Mr. Gebhardt provides technical support for customers of Dlubal Software and takes care of their requests.



;